Costco’s beloved seasonal pies, the Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie and Lattice Apple Pie, have sparked a long-running debate among shoppers. A taste test pitting the two against each other offers a detailed comparison of texture, flavor, and overall appeal. Fans of spiced pumpkin or crisp apple fillings will want to see which pie emerges as the clear winner. The breakdown reveals which dessert might become the standout choice for holiday baking—or just indulging.
Costco's Kirkland Signature Pumpkin and Lattice Apple Pies are seasonal icons, but which one is better? We tried both of these desserts to find out.
