Costco’s signature pumpkin pie has become a seasonal favorite for many shoppers, but the dessert isn’t without its critics. Common grievances among customers range from texture and flavor inconsistencies to concerns about the pie’s size and price. Some also report issues with freshness or packaging, raising questions about whether the beloved holiday treat lives up to expectations every year. Those curious about the debate—or considering a purchase—can weigh in on what makes—or breaks—their pumpkin pie experience.
For some, Costco's pumpkin pie is a holiday staple, but not everybody is a fan. Here are some of the most common complaints from shoppers.
